• Opinion1
Opinion

Opinion: Is the design world in danger of a creative vs commercial split?

Posted by Rob Alderson,

This week Rob Alderson looks at a design awards scheme with a difference and wonders if there’s too much of a divide between certain sections of the creative industries. As ever you can add your thoughts using the discussion thread below…

Last week I went to a design awards ceremony and didn’t see one hipster beard. Usually at this kind of affair you can’t move for stepping on the toes of a displaced extra from the TV series Girls, but this wasn’t like that at all. The Design Effectiveness Awards are run by The Design Business Association, and celebrates those projects which have had demonstrable results on the sales of the products in question. As the DBA writes on its website: “The best design is accountable, delivering both creatively and commercially. That’s the very essence of effective design.”

The big winner this year was B&B studio which oversaw every step of the branding and packaging for BEAR healthy fruit snacks. In three years, sales of BEAR went from nothing to – wait for it – £6.4 million. In 2012 the brand sold 30 million portions and as the judges noted: “Its pure and natural identity has convinced supermarkets to sit BEAR in the unbranded fresh produce aisle.”

Another big winner on the night was WPA Pinfold, which rebranded Croots, a specialist hunting clothing and equipment business formerly known as AC Supplies. Playing on ideas around traditional English heritage, the reported sales increase was nearly 18,000% (more than one wag on the night questioned what the starting point for this astonishing jump was).

Or what about The Team, and its campaign to raise awareness over gas safety issues which was credited with a 300% increase in high risk households having annual gas safety checks?

“The best design is accountable, delivering both creatively and commercially. That’s the very essence of effective design.”

The Design Business Association

I accept that these metrics are not infallible, and that other factors can come into play; in the case of BEAR a societal infatuation with healthier diets must at least be partly responsible. But the judges do try and take these things into consideration. More than one attendee at last week’s event remembered the furore over a lager brand that won big a few years ago, amid accusations that a gorgeous summer and a World Cup really accounted for its jump in sales.

But what last week mainly did was make me feel a bit embarrassed. We champion art and design of all kinds on It’s Nice That, but there is another, massive and very different design world of which I am shamefully ignorant. This feels like the coal face of design; the tea bag packaging that might not get a foot in on creative blogs but which must demonstrate its impact to hard-nosed brand managers.

I’m worried there is a schism between these two design worlds and I’m not sure that’s a healthy thing. DBA talk about the commercial and the creative; assessing design skewed too far towards either of these imperatives seems shortsighted.

Next year, I hope to see at least a couple of hipster beards at the Design Effectiveness Awards.

comments powered by Disqus
Ra

Posted by Rob Alderson

Editor-in-Chief Rob oversees editorial across all three It’s Nice That platforms; online, print and events. He has a background in newspaper journalism and a particular interest in art, advertising and photography. He is the main host of the Studio Audience podcast.

Most Recent: Opinion View Archive

  1. Graphicdesign_-opinion-itsnicethat-list

    A couple of months ago there was a lot of interest in this survey in which clients described the four worst types of creative agencies as they saw it. Now we have a chance to hear from the practitioners themselves, by way of Graphicdesign&’s in-depth industry study. Lucienne Roberts and Rebecca Wright have partnered with social scientist Nikandre Kopcke to create a questionnaire which explores “practice, perceptions and prejudices alongside the usual questions about age, education, work and pay.”

  2. List

    It’s fast approaching the time of all-nighters (not the fun ones), tears, last-minute panics and all the other things that come with the end of learning and the impending beginning of the terrifying thing they call real life. But like the mum that tells you you’re always the best and most talented and most beautiful, or the best friend that bursts into your house and pops the kettle on/pours the gin, we’re here to remind you of some of the advice that might be able to help you.

  3. Stevedaniels-hero-list

    There is an awful lot of discussion around starting a new magazine and for many creatively inclined people it remains one of their foremost ambitions. Last week Makeshift founder Steve Daniels wrote an excellent blog about the things to consider when planning a new publication, and in doing so summed up many things we too feel are important. Steve’s now become an advisor to the title he founded, a move which maybe gives him a little extra distance to write “not a guide to the nuts and bolts of finding a printer and selling subscriptions but a contemplation of the major elements that will set you up for success.”

  4. Kingadz-autenticity-list

    In the branding and advertising world, authenticity seems to have become the Holy Grail. Seemingly melded to whatever people need it to convey, it’s become a buzzword whose significance has mushroomed while its meaning has all but vanished. With this in mind King Adz, aka Adam N. Stone – whose new book Unbrandable is out this summer – considers what authenticity really means in a contemporary creative context. You can add your thoughts using the comment thread below…

  5. Kinfolk_14.cover

    The latest issue of Gym Class magazine has an eye-catching cover; with bold block capitals on a black background spelling out: “Nobody cares about your oh-so-cool, Kickstarted, tactile, minimalist unoriginal magazine.” It’s intended as a “call to action,” Gym Class editor Steven Gregor told MagCulture, “make magazines, and make them exceptional.”

  6. Applewtach-list-int

    The Apple Watch was officially unveiled yesterday (as was a super-thin 13.1mm new MacBook) and as ever the internet is awash with run-downs and reactions slobbering over the new products. For Wolff Olins design director Jan Eumann though, the imminent arrival of the new timepiece got him thinking about logo design, and in particular how app buttons have rehabilitated the logo. You can add your thoughts using the comment thread below…

  7. Rod-hunt-int-hero

    Do you really need an agent? Why? What do they actually do? In a talk hosted by The Illustrator’s Guild of Ireland at this year’s Offset festival a panel featuring Peepshow Collective’s Andrew Rae and Chrissie Macdonald, illustrators Rod Hunt and Matthew Griffin and Bernstein & Andriulli agent Sam Summerskill, we heard about how best to go about finding an agent, what they look for and what they get up to. Here’s what we learnt…

  8. Opinion-int-list

    After visiting the Design Indaba conference in South Africa, Rob Alderson asks if the leading designers working today favour humility and modesty over the cloying over-confidence of their predecessors. As ever you can add your thoughts using the comment thread below…

  9. Opinion-davidpearson-int-list

    Last week an interesting Twitter debate sprang up after a comment by graphic designer Andy Pressman who admitted that on a recent series he worked on it wasn’t always possible to read the books before designing the covers. So we decided to speak to a few other book cover designers and find out where they stand on this apparently quite divisive design issue; as ever you can add your thoughts using the comment thread below…

  10. Marckremers-opinion-int-list

    As part of the digital design showcase we are running with Represent, we interviewed Marc Kremers and found him in an unflinching mood as he detailed some of the issues he felt were affecting the industry. Such was the reaction to Marc’s piece both on the microsite and social media, we have decided (with his permission) to republish an excerpt of his interview here. You can add your thoughts using the comment thread below, and check out the dedicated digital design showcase here.

  11. Ije-nwokorie-indaba-sun

    As CEO of Wolff Olins, Ije Nwokorie is well-versed in the creative landscape; the forces that shape it and in turn how it shapes our world. Describing himself as “born in the US, bred in Nigeria and enlightened in England” he also has a global sensibility that sets him apart from many of his peers.

  12. Opinion-int-list

    A new survey has identified what clients see as the four worst types of design agency, and Rob Alderson suggests we should listen to what they had to say. As ever you can add your thoughts using the discussion thread below..

  13. Robertbye-opinion-list

    The intern debate is still one of the most talked-about issues whenever we meet young designers. This week Robert Bye wrote an interesting article about why, after three months interning in a design consultancy, he believes doing crappy jobs did sometimes make sense.