• Opinion-top

    Paul McCarthy: That Girl


What turns a group exhibition from a mishmash into a success? Comments welcome!

Posted by Maisie Skidmore,

This week assistant editor Maisie Skidmore asks what makes a good group show. Are they really all they’re cracked up to be, or are they poised for failure? Tell us what you think of them and which you’ve been to that were especially brilliant or terrible in the comments section below.

When it comes to art exhibitions, group shows are a decidedly hard one to get right. In my experience either you walk into a gallery and find yourself slapped around the face with work by more artists than you know what to do with, like a visual bodyslam that leaves you breathless and a bit bewildered. Or, work by disparate artists floats meaninglessly around huge expanses of white walls, unified only by vague themes.

The most celebrated group shows all seem to have taken place in the past, sparking the beginning of whole movements; Charles Saatchi’s history-making series of YBA shows in the late 80s, for example, or the exhibitions that launched the careers of the Impressionists. I was basically a kid in a huge Brutalist sweetshop then when I walked into the Hayward Gallery last week and found that their new exhibition The Human Factor: The Figure in Contemporary Sculpture has artfully skirted the potholes that group shows can so often fall into and created a new contemporary category entirely of its own.

The Hayward is well known for its prowess with creating impactful and exciting group exhibitions. Their Light Show last year sold out rapidly, and is still brought up frequently in conversations about what makes a good exhibition. Like the Light Show, The Human Factor has also been curated them thematically – it focuses specifically on the presence of the human body in contemporary sculpture, rather than trying to curate a series of works based on when they were made or what effect they have – and this is perhaps key to its success.

Secondly, the Hayward’s space is second to none when it comes to bringing very different works together in one exhibition. It’s an exciting space full of small rooms, corners, divisions and separate floors, so in what seems to be the art world’s equivalent of A-list privacy many of the works are afforded their own spaces and corners. As a result the space seems to unwind as you walk through it, and the variation in pieces adds excitement, rather than making the exhibition feel like a giant mishmash.

At the same time though, the selection of pieces incredible. Ghostlike, provocative, political and gut-wrenching in turn, each room reveals a new set of emotions delivered though the kind of wonderment that is akin only to what children in museums experience when seeing a mummy for the first time. From Maurizio Cattelan’s quiet goosebump-prickling sculpture of JFK in an open coffin, to Ryan Gander’s cheeky patriarchy-defying girls and Urs Fischer’s sexdoll-like wax woman with a wick protruding from her head which will burn throughout the duration of the exhibition. What holds the show together is the sense of awe that almost all of the pieces seem to inspire, whether through their hyper-reality, their positioning in a room or the way their presence seems to confront the viewer.

Even the invigilators seem to be uncomfortably aware of the tension in the sculptures; quietly bristling at the presence of the works around them, they look like they might be keeping watch over a haunted house rather than an innocent art exhibition.
The thematic curation, the brilliant use of the space, and the careful selection of jaw-dropping pieces all contribute, but in my opinion it’s this sense of awe which provides the continuity and fluency that holds the exhibition together. They might not be starting a movement, but the Hayward’s curators are carving out trends in contemporary sculpture.

What do you think makes a good group show? Have you seen any fantastic ones recently? Tell us below!

comments powered by Disqus

Posted by Maisie Skidmore

Assistant Editor Maisie joined It’s Nice That fresh out of university in the summer of 2013 and has stayed with us ever since. She has a particular interest in art, fashion and photography and is a regular on our Studio Audience podcast. She also oversees our London listings guide This At There.

Most Recent: Exhibition View Archive

  1. List

    Designing for the Design Museum’s Designs of the Year must be in many ways a dream project, in many ways a nightmare. Creating graphics that can seamlessly place disciplines as disparate as graphic design, furniture, product and architecture comfortably next to one another takes skill and an eye for leaving said projects to speak for themselves. Ok-RM’s graphics did just that, sitting back to let the viewer to make their own decisions about each project on its own merit, regardless of how it was made or by whom. Clean, well-spaced and scant typography work with clever colour-coding to form an overall aesthetic that more than deserves its place alongside the best designs of the past 12 months.

  2. List

    Listen up digital art types! If you’ve got great idea for a project that you haven’t been able to make happen, The Space may just be able to help. The not-for-profit venue has launched an open call to help a creative make that one crazy idea a reality, with funding and mentoring on offer. They say: “Nothing’s off limits; this is about pushing the boundaries and the project can take their point of departure from any artistic discipline, from music and film to visual arts and gaming.”

  3. Main

    Victoria Siddall has worked at Frieze for just over a decade and two years ago was made Director of Frieze Masters. Excitingly, just a few weeks ago she was appointed Director of Frieze Masters, Frieze New York and Frieze London. As well as being one of the most powerful women in the art world, Victoria is also my sister, so I was curious to find out how she’s feeling on the dawn of her new career.

  4. Main

    Imagine a dream world in which the heavy task of town planning was given over to the artists and creatives whose visions could ignite the city and bring out its most defining features. Some cities in the world are known for their cultural heritage: Nantes wasn’t one of these until 15 years ago, and since then it’s been a slow burn fuelled by the imagination of a group of risk-takers coralled by French public art impressario Jean Blaise and his curator David Moinard.

  5. Avlist1._alexander_rodchenko_costume_design_for_bedbug_1929__a._a._bakhrushin_state_central_theatre_museum

    For years I ventured no further than the hallowed halls of the lower floors of the V&A. And then, one day, like Lucy and Edmund tiptoeing upstairs to discover Narnia, I crept into the Theatre and Performance Galleries and found another magical wardrobe.

  6. List

    There are several cool job titles found in British history and Constable of the Tower of London is right up there. The Duke of Wellington took the office on route to becoming Prime Minister and made several major innovations including draining the moat, closing the Royal Menagerie and shutting down the taverns within its walls. All of which makes him sound like a prize spoilsport, but in fact after his tenure the Tower was both better-equipped for its military purposes and drawing more visitors than ever.

  7. List

    The South London Gallery describes Lawrence Weiner, whose new exhibition All in Due Course opened there last Friday, as a “reluctant pioneer of conceptual art,” which must be one of the coolest epithets going. The American artist has been creating his typographic wall sculptures since the 1970s when he first pioneered his unique medium which he maintains is not conceptualism but a kind of sculpture made using “language + the materials referred to.”

  8. Blist25.-simon-norfolk_-a-secuirty-guards-booth..._-herat_-2010-2011.-burke_norfolk.-courtesy-simon-norfolk

    Once upon a time, the church spires of New York offered an unrivalled view of the city. But in photographer Berenice Abbott’s Manhattan of the 1930s, skyscrapers shot up on every side and suddenly there were windows and back streets, balconies, construction sites and advertising billboards all crying out for a camera to capture their unique perspective of the metropolis. Changing New York is Abbott’s anatomy of the town, dissecting it, discovering its dramatic angles, dappled shadows and dilapidated dwellings. Her work is a fitting opening for the Barbican Art Gallery’s Constructing Worlds exhibition, exploring architecture and its relationship to the world through more than 250 images from 18 artists.

  9. Gwlist18

    Even if you haven’t seen it, you’ll have heard of it, because Gone With The Wind is still, 75 years after its release, the most successful blockbuster of all time. David O. Selznick’s multi-Oscar winning film has weevilled its way deep into the American – and the world’s – subconscious, creating so vivid a cultural memory we’re almost tricked into believing we lived through it all too. Even a lass like me, “southern” only in the east London sense of the word.

  10. Eslistst-columba's-wells_-londonderry-(derry)-_-n-ireland_-1965-(c)-edwin-smith_-riba-library-photographs-collection

    Edwin Smith’s England is a faraway place, and yet a familiar one. It’s a land inhabited by long-skirted ladies with perms, where brass cash registers are used on high streets fronted by butchers and bakers and grocers. No surprise then that the people’s poet Sir John Betjeman dubbed Smith a “genius at photography” because he has, in his vast collection of photographs of city and countryside, inside and outside, captured the essence of the now-distant England portrayed in the writer’s verse.

  11. List

    Imagine for a moment that the shoebox under your bed was filled not with photos of your Great Aunt June snoozing on the sofa last Christmas, but with photographs taken in space by astronauts on Apollo 14. For a lucky few at NASA this is (almost) true, and fortunately they’re more than happy to share their treasures with us proles in the form of a new exhibition at London’s BREESE Little Gallery.

  12. List

    20 years ago in 1994, little known designer Eike König set up his “graphic design playground” Hort, creating a community in the centre of Berlin where creatives could collaborate on ideas and client briefs side by side. Nowadays, the playground is slightly bigger, undertaking work for Nike, The New York Times and Walt Disney among others, but the underlying emphasis on collaboration and experimentation remains exactly the same.

  13. Olafurlist

    “Riverbed is running.” So tweeted Studio Olafur Eliasson yesterday – a poetic press release if ever I heard one – to announce the opening of the Danish-Icelandic artist’s latest epic installation. Something of a titan in the art world, having already created moon, he’s now built riverbed in the south wing of the Louisiana Musuem of Modern Art in Denmark.