My Favourite Music Video

My Favourite Music Video: Director Ninian Doff picks a Michel Gondry classic

Posted by Liv Siddall,

There’s a reason why Ninian Doff gets the best directorial commissions, and that’s his unparalleled sense of fun. The talented director made his name with a cool little music video about no-handed bike moves and has since made films for the likes of Graham Coxon, Darwin Deez and JJ Doom. He’s picked a Gondry, and he’s apologised for that, but we let him have it as you just don’t get many write-ups as passionate and technical as this. Take it away, Ninian.

Ninian Doff: The White Stripes – The Denial Twist

Choosing a Gondry video here feels very obvious and a bit uninspired, a bit like choosing The Beatles when asked for a favourite band, but it’d be impossible for me to choose anyone else. Like many people my life was changed forever when the original Gondry, Jonze and Cunningham Director’s Label DVDs came out. I watched those DVDs every day, multiple times, and learnt them off by heart like a favourite album. This is why I was delighted and surprised when years later I found this video on YouTube. It was made a few years after that DVD collection came out yet it’s an integral part of that incredible period in Gondry’s career, especially as it’s a White Stripes video. It’s just possible that it has slipped under some people’s radars and they can enjoy it now for the first time.

I think Star Guitar is Gondry’s most perfect music video, and therefore arguably one of the most perfect music videos ever made, but I love The Denial Twist more as it’s full of the mess and imperfections which Gondry does so well. The only criticism I’d give it is that to truly appreciate the video you do need it explained first! Fortunately there’s a great making of over here.

As anyone with a dodgy TV will know, television ratios often display wrong, so a 16:9 image (wide) sometimes appears on your TV as 4:3 (square) – this means all the people looked stretched and tall in your image. Likewise sometimes 4:3 gets displayed as 16:9 causing everyone to looked squashed. Gondry’s genius here is to physically create those distortions in camera and then correct them in post so they look normal, meaning that only the White Stripes get affected by the ratio mistake. So not only is the set squashed but he also uses little people wearing masks of squashed faces in the shot – so that when the image is stretched in post all the the proportions return to normal, except the White Stripes who now get distorted.

Likewise he then shoots other scenes using seven-foot-tall cast members wearing stretched masks in elongated sets so he can squash this image in post the other direction to create the regular image. Often he combines these two tricks into one set so the band can walk in real time from one distortion into another.

Like all great Gondry videos it’s both incredibly simple and mind-bogglingly complex. The fact that he then also pushed it to be a one-take video is just plain cocky.

  • 1_11.51.15

    The White Stripes: The Denial Twist. Directed by Michel Gondry

  • 2_11.51.15

    The White Stripes: The Denial Twist. Directed by Michel Gondry

  • 4_11.51.15

    The White Stripes: The Denial Twist. Directed by Michel Gondry

  • 5_11.51.15

    The White Stripes: The Denial Twist. Directed by Michel Gondry


Posted by Liv Siddall

Liv joined It’s Nice That as an intern in 2011 and is now one of our editors. She oversees and has a particular interest in illustration, photography and music videos. She is also a regular guest and sometime host on our Studio Audience podcast.

Most Recent: My Favourite Music Video View Archive

  1. List

    New York-based director Rajeev Basu has made plenty of curious projects that have kept us occupied for hours at a time, from this video game where your character punches itself in the face to stay awake to this collaborative project in which he invited a bunch of our favourite creatives to imagine what drones might look like once they become legal, so it makes perfect sense that his favourite music video be equally fascinating. And it is – if a little gory (it’s not for the fainthearted). Here he is explaining why he loves it so.

  2. List

    Tomas Leach is a longtime friend of It’s Nice That, a terrifically-talented director and a man who’s brimming with interesting ideas. But it’s funny how much more you learn about someone when you hear them talk about the work that inspired them to do what they love. So it is with Tomas’ choice, Daniel Wolfe’s Blind Faith for Chase & Status. It’s a video that’s always worth revisiting, but particularly so after you’ve read why Tomas thinks it’s a “period masterpiece.”

  3. Tool-list

    Art director, VJ and music video director Hans Lo can usually be found crafting retro-futuristic visuals for up-and-coming electronic acts like Com Truise, Jagwar Ma and world renowned acts like Simian Mobile Disco. So it may surprise you to discover that he’s really just a die-hard metal fan at heart – in particular a lover of the heavyweights of the early 1990s. His favourite music video reflects this perfectly; a stand-out track and seriously creepy piece of Savankmajeresque stop-motion for the legendary Tool directed by their guitarist Adam Jones.

  4. Mainpg

    I’m glad we caught Dan Wilton while he was on dry land with some time to spare, most of the time he’s cavorting around the world getting drunk in hotel rooms with really cool bands or pursuing his ongoing photography project looking at his beloved American football. We love Dan’s work, and Dan himself, and knowing how much he loves pop culture we asked him tot ell us about his favourite ever music video. Here he is…

  5. Rh

    Ryan Hopkinson’s work is a mesmerising merge of science and technology with art. It therefore seems perfect that, as such a fantastically forward-thinking film-maker and photographer, he’s chosen Björk’s video for All is Full of Love directed by Chris Cunningham, as his favourite music video. We’ve written about Ryan quite a few times, and posted about his photography as well as his stunning film work, all of which uses special effects spectacularly and surprisingly. Here is the fascinating conceptual visual artist on what he likes best about the legendary video, which seems more 22nd Century than anything 20th Century:

  6. Main

    Absolute banger this week from London-based filmmaker and photographer Phoebe Arnstein. As well as spending her days taking rather uncompromisingly beautiful photographs of her loved-ones, Phoebe has spent the last few years as a professional camerawoman, operating enormous machinery and creating videos for the likes of Jamie Isaac, South London Ordnance and Gang Colours among others. She kindly took time out from behind a lens of some sort to tell us about her favourite ever music video, and it’s an absolutely summery, 90s corker. Here she is…

  7. Main

    Nicos and Tom are a powerful animation duo from London whose recent project Tharis Sleeps was perhaps one of the most ambitious stop-motion films made in recent history. If you haven’t checked it out yet, go over here and then buy frames here. If you have, and you are already fans of these very talented young men’s work, have a read of their joint-favourite music video, the classic Money for Nothing by everyone’s Dad’s favourite band, Dire Straits.

  8. List

    For this week’s My Favourite Music Video we were lucky enough to get the pickings of Igor Haefeli of Daughter, the musical collective he fronts with Elena Tonra and Remi Aguilella. Together, the band are quickly making a name for themselves performing their haunting melodies and gorgeously broody sounds on stages as diverse as in front of the Tate’s recent exhibition Ruin Lust. Here he is explaining why he chose the eclectic mishmash that is The Avalanches video for Frontier Pyschiatrist, directed by Kuntz and Macquire.

  9. At-list

    Filmmaker Andrew Telling is something of a rare gem in his industry, in that each film he makes bears his signature in every single shot, yet he’s able to shift seamlessly from one client to another. It’s pretty apt then that he picked an equally talented filmmaker for his favourite music video, Kahlil Joseph, whose short for Kenzo had us raving a couple of weeks back. He too has an inexplicable presence in his films, making sublime, quietly poetic works that leave his viewers stunned time and again. We owe Andrew a pat on the back for giving us an excuse to rewatch his masterpiece for Flying Lotus’ Until the Quiet Comes.

  10. Main

    From someone who makes animations about the characters in Guess Who coming to life or short films about small characters meeting and falling in love in treacherous, alien landscapes, it’s pretty weird that Kirsten Lepore is utterly obsessed with Aphex Twin’s Windowlicker. But then again, who wasn’t completely hypnotised when they first saw it? It’s one of those things that remains with you forever, and yes, one of the best music videos of all time. 10 points to Gryffindor for Kirsten sending us a photo of her and a friend dressed up as Richard D. James and one of the creepy dancing girls.

  11. Main_11.36.08

    Since this feature started I have been praying someone would pick a video from my own youth that I could probably draw out the storyboard for in my sleep. Documentary-maker and spectacular director Toby Dye has picked one of the most controversial and utterly brilliant music videos from the noughties, Christina Aguilera’s Dirrty. Wet, wild and weird it’s a hard-hitting David LaChapelle masterpiece and Toby has justified his love for it beautifully. After you’ve stepped briefly into the past with a chap-wearing X-Tina, go to Toby’s site and check out the work he’s done for Unkle and Massive Attack and a documentary he made about dwarves in showbiz.

  12. Main

    Fantastic choice today from famed animator and Pick Me Up Select Julia Pott. Julia’s cute but informed work is known and enjoyed by many, particularly because it’s usually pretty hilarious, cute and touching all at once. Here she is telling us about why Jamie Thraves’ video for Radiohead’s Just is the best music video ever made. After you’ve checked this out, have a read of a great interview with Julia we did a few years back, it’s a real insight into her career as an animator.

  13. Main

    Good choice, Camilla! Surprised no one else has chosen Jonathan Glazer’s career-making epic of a music video yet. Camilla is an expert filmmaker whose work stretches across fashion films, music videos and promos. We particularly like her because she’s responsible for putting a member of Franz Ferdinand in one of those creepy horse masks for a music video. Here she is talking about one of the most legendary music videos of all time, Radiohead’s Street Spirit.