Thomas Steeles unearths the origins of the world’s most hated font, Comic Sans

An extract from the designer’s recent publication Comic Sans, Is it Really That Bad? delves into the history of the contentious font, uncovering the story of its creation and early uses.

Share

Playing the first chords of Smoke on the Water at a guitar shop; the Reliant Robin; Crocs; an unwelcome dad joke. All oddities that share the same kind of infamous hate as Comic Sans.

You could most likely step out onto the street and ask anyone if they knew what Comic Sans is (maybe with a visual prompt) and they’d respond with “yes” – followed by a look of confused disgust. Whether you’ve heard about it from social media, from your boss’ wordy email of why you need to use X font from now on, or even used it yourself, most people know of the font. By that notion, Vincent Connare, the creator of Comic Sans, has exclaimed that “I made the best font in the world.” Whether you believe that or not, it doesn’t exclude the fact it was, at one point, the second most complained about thing on Twitter and has a whole website dedicated to its banishment.

It may seem like a form of premature career suicide for a graphic design student hoping to secure a job in the creative industry, to write an essay about their career equivalent of Voldemort. But with the reasons why I should never use the font drilled into my brain since an early age, I want to question its legitimacy and unpick the anomaly that is Comic Sans, and answer: is it really that bad?

Left

Thomas Steeles: Comic Sans, Is it Really That Bad? (Copyright © Thomas Steeles, 2023)

Photography by Ell J Kennedy

Right

Thomas Steeles: Comic Sans, Is it Really That Bad? (Copyright © Thomas Steeles, 2023)

Above
Left

Thomas Steeles: Comic Sans, Is it Really That Bad? (Copyright © Thomas Steeles, 2023)

Photography by Ell J Kennedy

Right

Thomas Steeles: Comic Sans, Is it Really That Bad? (Copyright © Thomas Steeles, 2023)

Above

Thomas Steeles: Comic Sans, Is it Really That Bad? (Copyright © Thomas Steeles, 2023)

“Playing the first chords of Smoke on the Water at a guitar shop; the Reliant Robin; Crocs; an unwelcome dad joke. All oddities that share the same kind of infamous hate as Comic Sans.”

Thomas Steeles

The year was 1994 and Vincent Connare, a typographical engineer at the Microsoft Corporation, was reviewing a trial version of the soon-to-be-released program, Microsoft Bob. The programme was intended to be released as a more user-friendly interface for novices; hence, a big target audience was children.

Amongst the friendly visuals and accessible language was a virtual assistant in the form of a friendly yellow dog called Rover. Rover sat in the corner of your screen and used speech bubbles to communicate with the user.

However, Connare found a big issue with the typeface that Rover used to speak. See, Rover spoke in Times New Roman, which was such an inappropriate use of the font – as Times is typically used for large bodies of printed text (usually of a serious/academic nature) and is a complete contrast to the art style and personality of Rover.

In the early stages of designing the new font, Vincent looked to the hand-written type style present in comic books like Batman: The Dark Knight Returns and Watchmen, where the sans serif type was hand-rendered using a speedball pen and paper. Each word was meticulously crafted to fit in each speech bubble proportionally – so small variations were made to the type to suit the context of the frame it was housed in, as the design journalist and writer Simon Garfield uncovered. It’s understandable to see why Connare chose comics as his main source of inspiration; there’s a clear parallel to make between the speech bubbles used in comics and the speech bubbles that Rover uses. Additionally, the accessible, child-friendly atmosphere that Microsoft Bob wanted to achieve could be seen in the design of comic books – with the less-rigid hand drawn sans serif type, and bright colours.

Above

Thomas Steeles: Comic Sans, Is it Really That Bad? (Copyright © Thomas Steeles, 2023)

Connare, in around three days, created Comic Sans; however, the curvy, soft-edged font that we all know wasn’t the intended final form of the font. Comic Sans was meant for screen-use only, and due to the technical limitations in the mid 90s, Windows didn’t have anti-aliasing technology, which meant fonts were pixelated – as a result most fonts looked jagged and sharp. Knowing this, Connare specifically designed Comic Sans with aliasing in mind, so actually Comic Sans was only intended to be seen like what is shown in Figure 1.

Furthermore, because Comic Sans was designed with this in mind, it fares better than a font like Garamond when in aliased form as shown in Figure 2. Even though both fonts are at the same point size, Comic Sans utilises the space better whereas Garamond’s thinner serifs and stems suffer from the harsh pixelation.

Despite Connare’s efforts, the speech bubbles that Rover talked in were only designed to the size specifications of Times New Roman and as Comic Sans was slightly bigger, and given the little time that was left on the Bob project, the decision was made to scrap it – so Microsoft Bob was released Comic Sans-less.

When all hope seemed to have dissipated, Comic Sans rose from the ashes like a less graceful phoenix; later being released to Microsoft 3D Movie Maker which still adopted the type in helpful speech bubbles – a familiar home for Comic Sans. Even later when the bubbles were replaced by audio, Comic Sans remained in pop-up windows. Comic Sans’ influence spread even more once it reached Windows 95 Plus! Pack where it became a default font amongst Arial, Courier New, Times New Roman, and Wingdings. Its reign continued, later being used as a default font for Microsoft Internet Explorer and Microsoft Publisher. Sooner or later, due to the introduction of personal computers, Comic Sans invaded its way into every modern home, to be used by anyone, however they’d like.

Read more in Comic Sans, Is it Really That Bad? by Thomas Steeles, available here.

Above

Thomas Steeles: Comic Sans, Is it Really That Bad? (Copyright © Thomas Steeles, 2023)

Hero Header

Thomas Steeles: Comic Sans, Is it Really That Bad? (Copyright © Thomas Steeles, 2023)

Photography by Elliot J Kennedy

Share Article

Further Info

www.instagram.com/steeles_graphics

www.steeles.cargo.site

www.instagram.com/elliott.jk

Comic Sans, Is it Really That Bad? was made as part of of a university final project. All references have been linked out to in the text.

About the Author

Thomas Steeles

Thomas Steeles is a designer and independent publisher from Salford. His self-initiated work generally covers the peculiar, conceptual and misrepresented through typographic and editorial design.

It's Nice That Newsletters

Fancy a bit of It's Nice That in your inbox? Sign up to our newsletters and we'll keep you in the loop with everything good going on in the creative world.