Launch Recite Me assistive technology
A graphic divided into two panels. The left side shows a light blue silhouette of a person sitting atop a large sphere above the word “POV”. The right side is a solid light blue block with the text “GRAPHIC DESIGN HELPED MONETISE LONELINESS”.

How graphic design makes buying feel like belonging and brands feel like community

There’s an app for everything now… but in parallel, real-life communities and third spaces have ebbed away. Art director and graphic designer Glikeriya examines how design borrows the familiarity of relationships to sell services, and why designers should take those promises seriously.

Before asking anyone

Imagine this: you don’t own a car, and getting to work on your own takes two and a half hours and four different vehicles. One route even involves a ferry. Sometimes you ask your friends for a lift.

That’s how a woman I’d just met described getting to work. And the same journey back? I was already exhausted on her behalf.

It was naive of me to assume she had a problem. Friends gave her lifts, she asked for help and helped them back. This was her way of staying connected to a community she loved. I realised that in her situation, my first thought would have been to take an Uber, before even considering if someone I knew might be happy to drive me home.

Somewhere in my idea of being a competent adult was the assumption that you should get through the day without needing much from anyone. So many apps on my phone offer to solve almost any inconvenience with a friendly design. Just stay on your couch, we’ll take care of it! I understand the friendly appeal. I’m still relying on other people, of course. But deep down I know that I’ve just paid to avoid asking a friend and worrying if I’m causing inconvenience.

My new friend had people to call. Paying because there’s nobody to ask is different from paying to avoid asking. Loneliness is a profitable market. But so is the discomfort of needing someone. When you can’t lean on a neighbour or linger in a shared space, you can end up paying for what community used to be for.

Our need to belong is older than the business of making us feel like members. George Slavich’s Social Safety Theory proposes that feeling rejected or excluded can affect our stress and immune responses. Being accepted by other people has consequences beyond having someone to spend Friday with.

Sometimes there are people to meet and things to do together. Sometimes I’ve made an account, and the welcome is already doing quite a lot for a simple service. The photographs suggest friendship, the copy sounds like someone from my friend group could actually say it.

Graphic design makes buying feel like belonging and brands feel like community. And as graphic designers we’re quite happy to take credit for that, usually. The company doesn’t have to promise friendship if the invitation already feels like it came from a friend. When a service calls me a member, I always think: a member of what, exactly?

“So many apps on my phone offer to solve almost any inconvenience with a friendly design.”

Glikeriya

Tinder would like another chance

Take Porto Rocha’s identity for Tinder. Criticism would be much more convenient if everything wasn’t looking so good.

The emphatic wordmark and expressive serif make another attempt at dating feel less like a final exam. There’s even a fictional dating-columnist persona, “T”, behind the voice, someone imagined as having been through it herself. Tinder takes on the role of that one friend saying “You two should meet”, and it can introduce people who wouldn’t otherwise cross paths.

Within that friendly invitation, there’s also an offer to pay for a Boost, making your profile more visible for 30 minutes. The expressive type and familiar imagery give the brand a feeling of encouragement. Against that background, I can read the paid method almost as reassurance: perhaps there’s nothing wrong with me, I just haven’t been seen enough. The feeling of self-doubt hasn’t disappeared, but there is now something I can buy in response to it.

Tinder doesn’t have to make people lonely to monetise loneliness. It offers a paid advantage, and the design makes that offer feel like it comes from someone who totally understands why dating is difficult.

Design can help a service earn the emotional trust we associate with relationships, and that trust becomes commercially useful.

It would be absurd to blame the serif for the subscription model. In What Design Can’t Do, Silvio Lorusso describes designers being told they can change the world, then meeting clients who ask them to “make the logo bigger”. That feels painfully familiar. The subscription model may be beyond our control, but deciding how a brand looks and feels is central to our work. With Tinder, that means making a paid advantage feel like encouragement. “We only did the identity” doesn’t quite account for what the identity does. That gives us a responsibility to examine the promises we’re helping to make.

“It would be absurd to blame the serif for the subscription model... but deciding how a brand looks and feels is central to our work.”

Glikeriya

Design for belonging

I used to own an underground club and cultural centre in a former factory. We were doing the factory thing early, before it was cool, a fact I am clearly still finding ways to bring up. During the day it was functioning as a third place; at weekends, it became a rave.

I wanted people to feel they belonged and were safe there. The posters were part of that invitation, along with the music and the building itself. Maybe someone recognised their scene; maybe they just liked the idea of techno in a former factory. I could put together a line-up, design a poster and have some fun with the copy. The magic was seeing who responded and how people made connections once they were there. I couldn’t design where the conversations would go, and that was part of the appeal. In her book Raving, McKenzie Wark describes how the way people dance and respond to each other changes the night for everyone else. On a social media feed, the algorithm keeps deciding who you’re likely to come across based on who it thinks you already are.

Then I look at VIP areas in clubs. A club can mark off a section of the room and give it a look of its own, so even from a distance you know where the better night is supposed to be happening. There’s something cartoonishly capitalist about paying to leave the crowd and still needing it as an audience. I brings me back to Tinder’s 30-minute Boost, only here the upgrade comes with somewhere to sit and a bottle service.

Participation can change an online gathering too. Mindy Seu describes a workshop led by Prem Krishnamurthy and Kalaija Mallery where everyone unmuted, so laughter and interruptions could be heard. Such a small decision, but it gave people a way to feel each other there.

An invitation on Partiful or an event on Resident Advisor can give that participation somewhere to begin. Before anyone meets, the visual language already suggests who might belong there. Maybe we just like the same poster. A service can help a community exist without becoming the community itself or alienating its participants from each other.

“When the convenience of an app starts replacing the community itself, that’s where I see the problem.”

Glikeriya

Room for improvement

Sometimes paying for help is what saves me time to catch up with a friend. I don’t want to lose that convenience. But when the convenience of an app starts replacing the community itself, that’s where I see the problem.

I worry about what we lose every time we prefer paying for help through a service rather than asking a friend. When an app becomes a habit before we consider asking someone we know, we might be losing more than we think – especially when the service wears a friendly interface that suggests that we’re getting some of that connection anyway.

Graphic design can make buying feel like belonging. A company doesn’t have to promise friendship when its whole appearance suggests that it understands us. We recognise the references, get the joke, and start filling in the bank information. The service might deliver everything it advertised while leaving us without the connection that made the offer appealing.

As graphic designers, we make the invitation feel personal. And if someone expects more from a service, it doesn’t come from nowhere. We can’t take all the credit for making a brand feel human and none of the responsibility when people believe it.

Share Article

Further Info

About the Author

Glikeriya

—

Glikeriya is a New York-based art director and graphic designer. She co-founded a cultural centre and underground techno club in a former factory, where she spent almost eight years running and art directing the space. She is interested in graphic design as a tool for creating a sense of belonging in physical and digital spaces.

It's Nice That Newsletters

Fancy a bit of It's Nice That in your inbox? Sign up to our newsletters and we'll keep you in the loop with everything good going on in the creative world.